
by Madeline Miller
A Historical Fiction, 2011 by Ecco Press, 408 Pages
What I Didn’t Like:
- If you’re not familiar with Greek myths, starting where the story does could be a bit confusing. You get no names up front and very little info, just diving into the story. I will say it does work itself out pretty quickly.
- There are some mildly spicy scenes, so consider that a content warning if you need it.
- There are lulls in the story. Keep in mind I thought the same thing of the Iliad, so it’s not necessarily a bad thing. But it does control the pacing of the story and make it sort of awkward at times. Essentially it makes you want to stop and put the book down because it has slowed or nothing is happening.
- I didn’t love the ending. This part of the Achilles and Patroclus story is legend. We all know it. It should be the strongest and best part of this book. Instead, it falls completely flat and lacks the emotion you expected.
What I Did Like:
- Lyrical, which is wonderful because it matches the title and also gives the exact vibe you want for the subject matter.
- Achilles is projected in an interesting way. We keep the same cocky, self-assured character we’ve read about in other works but get a slightly softer view of him we don’t always see. It feels more balanced, making it easier to see why he’s lovable.
- Patroclus is painted in a good light. He’s often portrayed as weak. I liked seeing his strengths highlighted.
Who Should Read This One:
- Fans of Greek mythology who want that “other take” on the myth.
- Anyone who wants a light introduction to Greek mythology or legends can start with Achilles. He’s an interesting character and his story is relatable.


Leave a Reply