
by Nicola Skinner
MG Fantasy, 2019 by Harper Collins, 368 Pages
What I Didn’t Like:
- As is typical for middle grade books, this one has a lot of over-the-top and obviously bad decisions from adults in charge. It does come with good lessons, of course, but as an adult it makes you roll your eyes a bit.
- The main character is naive, which is also common for a middle grade book.
- This one really is intended for a middle grade audience (think 10-14 or so) because it is a bit immature in a lot of ways. That won’t affect my rating because the author and publisher are very clear about this being their intended age range. BUT, if you’re not a reader who normally delves into books for this age group, proceed with caution.
What I Did Like:
- OMG the boards on this hardcover are BEAUTIFUL. That won’t affect my rating, I just had to point that out.
- The THIS IS A WARNING chapter sets the voice of the MC well. You understand the sense of humor right away and connect with her in just a few short pages.
- Adorable character growth from the main character and an antagonist combined with beautiful illustrations and a solid message.
Who Should Read This One:
- Middle grade readers who want fun and a little fantasy!
My Rating: 4 Stars
- The storyline is original and the message is great.


Leave a Reply