
by Lorenzo Carcaterra
A Historical Fiction, 2003 by Ballentine Books, 352 Pages
What I Didn’t Like:
- I really struggled to connect with any of the characters in this one. This may be due to the fact that we jump locations and groups a lot or it could be because the focus is really the action. Either way, a lack of connection to anyone made it tough to get into the story.
- Repetitive. A lot of the scenes are very similar, which makes it hard to keep track of exactly what’s happening or if progress is being made.
- This is historical fiction but it reads heavy on the fiction and light on the historical, if that makes sense. I would’ve preferred it to read a bit more grounded in history. This became especially true as I did a little more research into the events described and found what are either plot holes or inaccuracies.
What I Did Like:
- Children are the focus here, as intended. The adult characters who enter the story do so to “assist” more than “take over” or “lead”. That works for this story.
- Detailed action scenes. If you’re looking for a war book with action you can clearly picture, this delivers.
- It will intrigue you to research the events further, which I believe may have been the point. This book tiptoes around some big events that will leave you curious for more.
Who Should Read This One:
- Fans of action driven books about war may appreciate this fictionalised take on the Four Days of Naples.


Leave a Reply