
by Caro Claire Burke
A Contemporary, 2026 by Knopf, 400 Pages
What I Didn’t Like:
- The college backstory, intended to give forgiveness and understanding to Natalie, is dry and frustrating compared to the rest of the story. Really an uneven amount of time is given to this part of the storyline when that’s not where your readers will want to focus.
- The middle of the story drags a bit. By this point, you hate Natalie. You don’t feel sorry for her or for what she’s creating. That makes it difficult to follow her story.
- This book is very different from what I expected reading the description. While it didn’t turn out to be inherently bad it was shocking. I like things that shock me and go in a direction I wasn’t expecting, but be warned!
What I Did Like:
- This book gives a master class on creating an awful character you’ll hate within one chapter. Even if you have NO opinion about influencers, trad wives, or incredibly rich out-of-touch people, the way Natalie carries herself in the opening chapter will make you hate her. It’s intentional and it’s brilliantly written.
- This POV shows a deteriorating mental state in a remarkable way. You are able to see this character unraveling through the text, the language choices, and the repetition. It’s very well done as a character study.
- The ending works well. No spoilers but it’s exactly what this story needed. It ties up all the little threads the author left dangling through the prose and turned it into a unique picture.
Who Should Read This One:
- Contemporary fans who appreciate an unlikable and unreliable narrator, especially when it’s worth it for the character study.
- If you’re writing a story or generally interested in how authors create characters you’ll have genuine opinions about this is one I’d absolutely put on the list.


Leave a Reply